East Side Mags East Orange

East Side Mags is highly praised for its welcoming atmosphere and knowledgeable staff, making it a favorite among comic and sports card collectors. Customers appreciate the broad selection of comics and collectibles, along with frequent community events such as signings and drawing classes. However, there are concerns about inconsistent customer interactions, with some feeling uncomfortable with specific staff members’ behavior. Overall, the shop is noted for its clean, organized layout and community focus.

• A variety of community events and activities
• Support for local artists and musicians
• Inclusive environment for newcomers and veterans

Prices :

Single Cards: $1-20, Hobby Boxes: $100-300, Graded Cards: $50-1000+

Speciality :

Community-driven comic and sports cards shop with a wide variety of collectibles

Event Schedule :

Best for :

Casual fans, collectors of various ages, and families

FAQ :

Does it have vintage sports cards ?

Yes, with a focus on various comic book eras and collectibles

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have graded cards in stock ?

Yes, they have a selection of graded cards (PSA, BGS, SGC)

Host break sessions ?

Yes, they host events and possibly breaks

Whats sports do they have ?

Mainly focused on comics, with a selection of sports cards and collectibles

Trade in ?

Not specified

Community / Regular players ?

Yes, there is an active community with regular events

Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?

The staff is knowledgeable and helpful, assisting both new and veteran collectors

Pro tips :

Visit during event days for the best community experience

Ask about signing up for pull lists to secure your favorite titles