America’s Pastime Paterson

Customer reviews of America’s Pastime reveal a polarized experience, with many praising the owner, Rich, for his friendliness, helpfulness, and extensive inventory of vintage and contemporary cards. However, several customers described unpleasant interactions with the owner, citing rudeness and unprofessionalism, which affected their shopping experience. Positive feedback highlights the store’s welcoming atmosphere and competitive pricing, while negative reviews express frustration over customer service shortcomings.

• Wide variety of vintage baseball cards
• Layaway options available
• Personalized assistance in finding specific cards

Prices :

Singles: $1-100+, Vintage packs: $50-500+

Speciality :

Vintage baseball cards and a wide variety of sports cards

Event Schedule :

Best for :

Casual fans and serious collectors looking for vintage cards

FAQ :

Does it have vintage sports cards ?

Yes, specializes in vintage baseball cards

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have graded cards in stock ?

Yes, has a variety of graded cards from PSA and other grading services

Host break sessions ?

Not specified

Whats sports do they have ?

Primarily baseball, but includes other sports as well

Trade in ?

Not specified

Community / Regular players ?

Yes, has an active community with positive mentions of customer interactions

Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?

Staff’s expertise varies; while Rich is praised for his knowledge, there are complaints about unhelpfulness from some reviews

Pro tips :

Be clear about what you’re looking for to avoid misunderstandings with the owner.

Consider visiting during less busy times for a better interaction with the staff.