AJ Collectables West Allis

The store has mixed reviews, with customers appreciating the friendly staff and range of products, especially newer collectors who find the guidance helpful. However, several reviewers have expressed concerns about low offers when selling cards, perceived changes in staff knowledge, and pricing being higher than expected for some items. The need for better organization within the store and communication about offers was also mentioned, indicating areas needing improvement despite some positive experiences.

• Loyalty program with promotions and giveaways
• Helpful staff with industry knowledge
• Online presence for easy purchasing and shipping

Prices :

Hobby boxes: $100-300, Singles: $1-100+, Sealed products: $20-200

Speciality :

Modern and graded sports cards, with a focus on a friendly customer experience.

Event Schedule :

Best for :

Casual fans and beginner collectors looking for guidance and a wide variety of products.

FAQ :

Does it have vintage sports cards ?

No

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have graded cards in stock ?

Yes, they carry graded cards (PSA, BGS, SGC).

Host break sessions ?

Yes, they host box breaks and events.

Whats sports do they have ?

Covers all major sports, with a strong selection in modern cards.

Trade in ?

Offers cash or store credit, although many customers reported lowball offers.

Community / Regular players ?

Yes, there is an active collector community with events and promotions.

Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?

The staff is generally knowledgeable, although some recent changes have led to concerns.

Pro tips :

Visit during events or promotions to maximize value and learn more about the hobby.

Engage with staff for guidance on collecting and pricing, especially if new to the hobby.