The 35 best sports cards stores in Wisconsin, Wisconsin

Overall, customers highlight the store’s extensive selection of sports cards and memorabilia, with a particular emphasis on Packers-related items. Positive feedback frequently mentions the knowledgeable and friendly staff who provide excellent customer service and fair…

Customers generally appreciate the extensive selection of trading card games (TCGs), board games, and collectibles available at this store, highlighting the friendly and knowledgeable staff who are eager to assist, especially with collections. However, there…

Customers widely praise the store for its friendly atmosphere and exceptional customer service, with many noting the owner, Chris, as knowledgeable and personable. The diverse inventory of sports cards and collectibles, including unique vintage items…

The store has received mixed reviews, with some customers praising the staff’s friendliness and knowledgeable service, as well as the wide selection of products available. However, there are significant complaints about high prices that exceed…

The store features a large selection of trading cards, particularly for sports and Pokémon, with many customers praising the owner for his friendliness and knowledge. However, several reviews noted inconsistencies in customer service and communication,…

Farmstead Outdoors has a large store with a welcoming atmosphere, praised for its knowledgeable and friendly staff. Customers appreciate the variety of sports and pet supplies, as well as competitive pricing. However, concerns have been…

Fox Cities Cards is highly regarded by customers for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, as well as its wide selection of cards and memorabilia across various price ranges. Many reviews highlight the welcoming atmosphere for…

Customers appreciate Jim’s expertise and willingness to provide personalized service, though some have reported feeling unwelcome or undervalued upon initial visits. While prices may be higher for certain items, the shop is recognized for its…

Customers appreciate the wide selection of autographed sports memorabilia, particularly for Wisconsin teams like the Packers, Brewers, and Badgers. The store is known for its friendly and helpful staff, making it a popular destination for…

Affordable Rare Coins in Appleton is noted for its diverse selection of coins and sports cards, with many customers expressing satisfaction with their knowledgeable staff and reasonable prices. However, some negative reviews highlight unprofessional interactions,…

Chimera Hobby in Appleton is praised for its extensive selection of board games, TCGs, and comics, making it a go-to spot for local gamers. Despite an enthusiastic collection and friendly knowledgeable team, some customers reported…

The store generally offers a strong selection of sports cards and memorabilia, with an owner who is praised for his knowledge and customer service when he is attentive. Many customers express satisfaction with the variety…

Customer reviews highlight a strong selection of sporting goods but point to significant issues with customer service and staff responsiveness. While some shoppers appreciate the variety and competitive pricing, many express frustration over employees being…

Customers praise this store for its friendly and helpful atmosphere, with many appreciating the owner Gary for his dedication to customer service and deep knowledge of the products. The selection is noted as being good…

Customers rave about Beckett Castle TCG for its competitive prices, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and a welcoming environment suitable for both novices and experienced collectors. The store offers a wide range of products while maintaining…

Customer reviews highlight an overwhelmingly positive experience at this card shop, emphasizing the friendly and knowledgeable staff who are particularly attentive to younger collectors. Many reviews praise the fair pricing and generous trade values offered,…

Customers consistently praise the warm atmosphere and knowledgeable staff, making it easy for newcomers to feel welcomed and engaged. The store is known for its extensive selection of tabletop games, Magic the Gathering products, and…

Ultimate Authentics offers a diverse selection of both vintage and modern sports cards, with many customers praising the knowledgeable and friendly staff who are committed to helping collectors find what they need. The store is…

Customers appreciate the wide variety of merchandise and the friendly, helpful staff, with positive comments highlighting the store’s atmosphere and selection of sports and trading cards. Some concerns were raised regarding pricing, which many felt…

Customer reviews generally praise the store for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, extensive inventory of sports cards and trading card games (TCGs), and fair pricing in comparison to market values. However, there are some criticisms…

The store has a mixed reputation; while some customers praise the knowledgeable and friendly staff and the community atmosphere favorable for card games, others report negative experiences related to trade-in practices and management. Concerns include…

Customer reviews highlight that while the store has a friendly atmosphere and a decent selection of Pokémon and Magic cards, many feel that the pricing is consistently above market rates. There are complaints about the…

E5 Sports is widely praised for its exceptional customer service and knowledgeable staff, particularly owner Brian, who consistently receives accolades for his professionalism and friendliness. Customers appreciate the store’s fair pricing and diverse inventory of…

The sports cards store offers a wide selection of graded and modern cards, appealing to collectors and casual fans alike. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable staff and organized inventory, which enhance their shopping experience. However, there…

DICK’S Sporting Goods in Wausau, WI has received mixed reviews from customers. Many praise the wide variety of sports equipment and clothing available, as well as the cleanliness and organization of the store. However, multiple…

Customers consistently praise the knowledgeable and friendly service provided by Jeff, the owner, highlighting his willingness to share stories and offer expert advice on card grading. The store boasts a good selection of cards, particularly…

Customers rave about the extensive selection of games and friendly, knowledgeable staff at Gnome Games. Visitors appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the attentive service they receive when seeking advice on games, including specialized recommendations that…

Customers praise Undercity Games for its welcoming atmosphere, knowledgeable and friendly staff, and a well-organized selection of gaming cards. The store is recognized as a hub for both new and veteran players of trading card…

Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, knowledgeable staff, and extensive selection of games and accessories at Sanctum. The store is well-organized and clean, making it a comfortable spot for gaming and shopping. However, some reviews mention…

PopCon Shop is a vibrant and welcoming destination for pop culture enthusiasts, praised for its impressive selection of collectibles that includes Funko Pops, anime figures, and unique merchandise. Customers appreciate the knowledgeable and friendly staff…

The store has mixed reviews, with customers appreciating the friendly staff and range of products, especially newer collectors who find the guidance helpful. However, several reviewers have expressed concerns about low offers when selling cards,…

The store boasts a vibrant atmosphere with an extensive selection of sports and Pokémon cards, praised for its knowledgeable and friendly staff, especially Alex and the owner. Customers appreciate the competitive pricing and the fun…

The store offers a wide selection of vintage collectibles, including sports cards, yet suffers from issues related to disorganization, arbitrary pricing by the owner, and a generally unfriendly atmosphere. While some customers appreciate the eclectic…

Customer feedback on this store is mixed, with some praising the friendly and helpful service, particularly from staff members like Danny. However, there are significant concerns regarding pricing, with multiple reviews describing the store as…