The 35 best sports cards stores in New York, New York

(958 reviews)

This shop is well-regarded by customers for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, wide selection of trading cards, collectibles, and anime merchandise. Many reviewers appreciate the cozy atmosphere and the owner’s willingness to help, often going…

(89 reviews)

Tommy’s Figz is highly praised for its wide selection of vintage toys and collectibles, including sports cards, VHS tapes, and other nostalgic items. Customers love the friendly and knowledgeable owner, Tommy, who is described as…

(89 reviews)

Customers appreciate the welcoming and knowledgeable staff, particularly praising Alex for his assistance. The store is noted for its spacious environment ideal for gaming and pack openings, with fair pricing that is often below market…

(87 reviews)

Customers rave about the diverse selection of collectibles, comics, and toys available at this store, noting the friendly and knowledgeable staff that enhances the shopping experience. Regular mentions of its organized layout and welcoming atmosphere…

(87 reviews)

Sports World is highly regarded for its customer-friendly atmosphere, extensive selection of fitted caps, and jerseys for a variety of sports. Many customers appreciate the quality of products and prompt shipping; however, there are consistent…

(85 reviews)

The New York Yankees Team Store is known for its wide selection of Yankees merchandise and friendly staff, making it a popular stop for fans before games. However, some customers have raised concerns about the…

(84 reviews)

Hall of Frames is praised for its knowledgeable staff, exemplified by owner Tom who is consistently described as helpful and fair. The store has a broad selection of sports cards, memorabilia, and collectibles, particularly strong…

(82 reviews)

The store is noted for its competitive pricing and an extensive selection of trading cards, particularly in the TCG (Trading Card Game) market. Positive reviews highlight the welcoming environment and knowledgeable staff, making it a…

(77 reviews)

Piece of the Game has garnered praise for its modern, clean, and organized atmosphere, with a wide variety of products including sports cards and trading card games like Pokémon and Magic: The Gathering. Customers love…

(76 reviews)

The store offers a good variety of sports cards across multiple games like Pokémon, Magic, and various sports. Customers have noted positive interactions with staff, particularly regarding assistance and accommodating trade events. However, there are…

(74 reviews)

Al’s House of Sports Cards offers a mixed experience based on customer feedback. Many praise the owner, Al, for his friendliness and willingness to work with customers, often highlighting his fair prices and extensive knowledge…

(73 reviews)

This card shop is highly praised for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, fair pricing, and wide variety of products, making it a great spot for collectors. Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the owner’s willingness…

(67 reviews)

The store is generally praised for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, making it an inviting place for collectors of all kinds. Many customers appreciate the variety of items available, especially in trading cards and retro…

(67 reviews)

The store offers an eclectic mix of sports cards, with some positive experiences highlighting good prices and knowledgeable staff. However, numerous customers reported issues with inconsistent hours, poor customer service, and a lack of attention…

(66 reviews)

Big Slab Daddy’s Sports Cards has received overwhelmingly positive feedback for its extensive selection of sports and Sports cards, with many customers praising the owner and staff for their friendliness and expertise. The store is…

(66 reviews)

This sports card store is a beloved local spot praised for its friendly and knowledgeable staff who provide excellent customer service. Many customers highlight the store’s diverse inventory, particularly in Pokémon cards and graded cards,…

(66 reviews)

Overall, The Collector’s Friend is praised for its friendly and knowledgeable owner, Mickey, who offers a wide selection of sports cards, Pokémon cards, and memorabilia. Customers appreciate the fair pricing and the opportunity to negotiate…

(64 reviews)

The store offers a friendly atmosphere and knowledgeable staff, particularly Frank, who is highly praised for his good customer service and fair pricing on various items such as Pokémon cards. However, multiple reviews highlight serious…

(59 reviews)

The New York Mets Team Store at Citi Field offers a wide range of merchandise from jerseys to trinkets, appealing to passionate Mets fans. Many customers highlight the extensive selection and the helpful, friendly staff.…

(57 reviews)

GG Cards and Breaks receives consistently high praise for its extensive selection of sports cards, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and fair pricing. Customers appreciated the welcoming atmosphere, the ability to negotiate prices, and the willingness…

(54 reviews)

The store generally has a good reputation for its extensive selection of sports and Pokémon cards, with many customers praising the friendly and knowledgeable staff. However, some reviews reported instances of early closures and mixed…

(52 reviews)

The store is praised for its exceptional customer service, knowledgeable staff, and expansive selection of New York Yankees merchandise, making it a go-to choice for fans and collectors alike. Customers highlight the dedication of the…

(51 reviews)

Customers rave about this store for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, competitive pricing, and an impressive selection of Pokémon cards alongside other trading card games. Many reviews highlight the welcoming atmosphere for families and newcomers,…

(5 reviews)

Customer reviews reflect a mixed experience, highlighting the extensive inventory of memorabilia and other sports items, praised for authenticity and a friendly atmosphere. However, concerns were raised about in-house grading practices, leading to mispriced cards,…

(44 reviews)

JB’s Cards is highly regarded for its extensive selection of sports cards and memorabilia, as well as its knowledgeable and friendly staff, led by Justin. Customers frequently commend the store’s family-friendly atmosphere, fair pricing, and…

(43 reviews)

The store has a mixed reputation among customers. Many praise the staff for their friendliness and fair negotiations on items sold, highlighting the welcoming atmosphere and a good range of collectibles, particularly vintage items. However,…

(4 reviews)

Customers rave about the friendly and knowledgeable staff, particularly highlighting employees like Bennet and Luke for their helpfulness. The store offers a great selection of singles and graded cards, appealing to both casual collectors and…

(39 reviews)

The store has garnered positive reviews for its knowledgeable and friendly staff, making it a great place for new and seasoned collectors alike. Customers appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the limited but dedicated inventory of…

(38 reviews)

DJ Cards is praised for its great selection of both modern and vintage cards, assisted by knowledgeable and friendly staff. Many customers appreciate the organization and cleanliness of the store, as well as the owner…

(37 reviews)

Customer reviews for this sports cards store reflect a polarizing experience, with some praising helpful staff and the quality of signed memorabilia, while others criticize high prices, poor customer service, and unpleasant shopping experiences. There…

(36 reviews)

Customers appreciate the store’s impressive inventory and knowledgeable staff, particularly praising Neil for his exceptional customer service and expertise. Many reviews highlight the friendly atmosphere, making it a welcoming space for collectors. However, there are…

(353 reviews)

Overall, the store is recognized for its vast selection of Funko Pop figures, with many customers praising their excellent shipping and overall service. However, there are significant concerns about the pricing on TCG products, which…

(346 reviews)

The store is known for its friendly staff and community atmosphere, making it a great place for casual gamers and collectors. Customers appreciate the good selection of singles and the competitive pricing on various trading…

(34 reviews)

The store is praised for its extensive selection of sports merchandise across various sports, with friendly and helpful staff dedicated to customer service. However, some concerns arise regarding stock shortages, inconsistent pricing, and a few…

(320 reviews)

At WeTheHobby, customers rave about the vast selection of sports and collectible cards, along with a positive atmosphere that welcomes both new and seasoned collectors. While many reviews highlight the knowledgeable and friendly staff, creating…

Loading…

Cities around