The 35 best sports cards stores in New Jersey, New Jersey

(97 reviews)

The store has received overwhelmingly positive feedback for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, particularly praising Khalil for his assistance and customer service. Customers appreciate the well-organized inventory that includes a vast selection of sports, Magic…

(9 reviews)

Customer reviews commend the store for its welcoming atmosphere and knowledgeable staff. Many customers appreciate the community-centric vibe, likening it to a throwback coffee shop where card enthusiasts can gather. Queries about the variety of…

(9 reviews)

Customers rave about the welcoming atmosphere and the knowledgeable staff at this card shop, highlighting its extensive selection of Pokémon cards alongside a growing sports card inventory. Visitors appreciate the fair pricing and community-oriented environment,…

(9 reviews)

Customers rave about the store’s friendly and knowledgeable staff, offering a clean and organized environment with a wide selection of trading cards, including Magic, Pokémon, and Yu-Gi-Oh. Many reviews highlight the store’s fair pricing and…

(8601 reviews)

The store is appreciated for its wide variety of sports cards, especially graded cards. Customers commend the selection and variety offered, but there are notable concerns regarding staff behavior and customer service, with reports of…

(85 reviews)

Customers rave about Sports Minded Unlimited in Warren, NJ, highlighting its extensive selection of memorabilia, particularly focused on the New Jersey Devils. The staff is consistently described as friendly and knowledgeable, ensuring a welcoming atmosphere…

(82 reviews)

Customers express a mix of experiences, citing high-quality products and responsive customer service as strengths, particularly in resolving issues promptly. However, concerns focus on delayed shipping, order cancellations, and inconsistent fulfillment practices. Some shoppers report…

(805 reviews)

Customers rave about the extensive selection and knowledgeable, friendly staff at Digital Press, a retro gaming haven in Clifton, NJ. The store offers not just games but also systems and repairs, features arcade cabinets, and…

(80 reviews)

The store has a mixed reputation among its customers. While some praise the knowledgeable staff and variety of card games available, others express dissatisfaction with the store’s atmosphere, citing issues of bullying and harassment instigated…

(8 reviews)

Customers frequently praise Josh’s professionalism, deep knowledge of sports cards, and personalized service, creating a feeling of partnership rather than mere transactions. However, there are criticisms regarding buy/sell pricing, with one reviewer feeling that sellers…

(74 reviews)

Victory Point stands out as a welcoming hub for board game enthusiasts, showcasing a strong selection of products and hosting community events. Customers praise the friendly and knowledgeable staff, and the variety of games available.…

(73 reviews)

Customers generally praise Dave & Adam’s for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, diverse inventory, and welcoming atmosphere. Many found great deals on both sports cards and Pokémon products, highlighting the store’s organization and breadth. However,…

(71 reviews)

Overall, the store receives praise for its welcoming atmosphere and knowledgeable staff, especially the positive energy from staff members like Grisbel and Paul. Customers appreciate the fair pricing and the store’s family-friendly environment, making it…

(70 reviews)

The store is celebrated for its wide variety of collectibles, especially Pokémon and Yu-Gi-Oh cards, and offers a friendly atmosphere where local players gather. While many customers praise the staff’s friendliness and the store’s organized…

(7 reviews)

Customers praise Effortlex for their knowledgeable and friendly staff, particularly noting Yi’s willingness to assist in finding cards and providing good deals. The store’s focus on graded products has been well-received, though some customers mention…

(7 reviews)

Customers rave about the friendly and welcoming staff, as well as the store’s diverse selection of singles and competitive pricing. The active community engagement through events like Magic the Gathering tournaments is a notable strength.…

(69 reviews)

East Coast Connection in Lyndhurst, NJ, is praised for its extensive selection of sports cards and memorabilia, ranging from vintage to modern products across various sports. The owner, Mike, is noted for his honesty, knowledge,…

(68 reviews)

Customers appreciate the spacious, clean environment and the welcoming atmosphere, which is particularly accommodating for families and groups, including those with special needs. The staff are recognized for their patience and expertise, providing excellent recommendations…

(68 reviews)

Customer reviews of America’s Pastime reveal a polarized experience, with many praising the owner, Rich, for his friendliness, helpfulness, and extensive inventory of vintage and contemporary cards. However, several customers described unpleasant interactions with the…

(67 reviews)

The store is well-regarded for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, extensive selection of trading card games (TCGs), and a welcoming community atmosphere, making it a great place for casual fans and dedicated collectors alike. Various…

(655 reviews)

Customers consistently praise MonkeySports Woodbridge for its knowledgeable and attentive staff, who provide personalized service and expertise in fitting and selecting sports equipment. Many reviews highlight the friendly demeanor and exceptional patience of employees, especially…

(65 reviews)

The store offers a welcoming environment with a strong community feel, frequently hosting events such as Commander nights and casual tournaments. Customers appreciate the fair pricing and knowledgeable staff, enhancing the overall experience. However, there…

(624 reviews)

This store is highly praised for its extensive inventory and exceptional customer service, with many customers lauding the owner’s helpfulness and expertise. Some reviews noted concerns about a few overpriced items and a credit card…

(62 reviews)

The store is recognized for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, particularly Mike, who often provides useful advice to customers. Many patrons appreciate the welcoming atmosphere and the store’s ability to cater to younger collectors with…

(57 reviews)

This store is known for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, making it a welcoming space for collectors of all ages, particularly for those interested in Pokémon cards and comics. Customers appreciate the wide variety of…

(55 reviews)

Customers rave about Wheelhouse’s exceptional selection of sports and Pokémon cards, combined with their friendly and knowledgeable staff. Many highlight the engaging atmosphere and the staff’s willingness to educate both new and experienced collectors, making…

(544 reviews)

Brave New Worlds offers a wide variety of comics, figures, and collectibles that cater to all tastes, from mainstream to indie selections. The store is praised for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, creating an inviting…

(543 reviews)

This store has received mixed reviews, with many praising its welcoming atmosphere, knowledgeable staff, and variety of games, especially Magic: The Gathering and Sports. Customers have noted fair pricing on singles, but there are complaints…

(54 reviews)

Scarlet Fever receives praise for its extensive selection of Rutgers merchandise and friendly staff, making it a popular destination for fans. Customers appreciate the store’s better pricing compared to nearby competition, with a strong focus…

(516 reviews)

Jokers Child Comics is praised for its incredible selection of comics and collectibles, along with an exceptionally knowledgeable and welcoming staff. Customers appreciate the family-friendly atmosphere and diverse variety available, ensuring both casual fans and…

(51 reviews)

The store has received strong praise for its extensive selection of Phillies merchandise and excellent customer service, with many customers reporting helpful staff and good clearance prices. However, there are concerns about inconsistencies in store…

(504 reviews)

The Pok Court is praised for its extensive selection of both modern and vintage Pokémon products, fair market pricing, and friendly staff who are knowledgeable about the trading card game. Customers appreciate the wide range…

(50 reviews)

The store is praised for its friendly and helpful staff, particularly in providing personalized service such as free gift wrapping, which is a favorite among customers. Many reviews highlight the joyful atmosphere created by the…

(5 reviews)

Customers rave about the store’s awesome atmosphere and the friendly, helpful owner, highlighting the great customer service. However, specific details regarding inventory diversity and specialty focus are not specified, which could leave some collectors curious…

(494 reviews)

Customers rave about the cleanliness, organization, and wide selection of modern and vintage collectibles, particularly in comics and TCGs including Pokémon. The staff is often described as friendly and knowledgeable, creating a welcoming atmosphere for…

Loading…

Cities around