Profile
Keep It Strange Collectibles is acclaimed for its friendly and knowledgeable staff who are passionate about a wide range of collectibles, including sports cards, toys, and comics. Customers appreciate the variety of items available, particularly vintage and graded cards. However, some feel that prices are slightly higher compared to other retailers, leading to mixed sentiments on value. The store’s vibrant atmosphere and the community feel enhance the shopping experience, making it a popular destination despite minor concerns about pricing.
- Loyalty program for frequent shoppers
- Monthly spotlight on new products and sales
- Community gatherings for collectors
Prices :
Singles: $2-200+, Graded cards: $50-1000+, Packs/Boxes: $5-500
Speciality :
Sports cards, action figures, and pop culture memorabilia
Event Schedule :
Best for :
Casual collectors and pop culture enthusiasts
FAQ :
Does it have vintage sports cards ?
Yes, they do carry vintage cards from various eras including pre-1980s items
Does it restock frequently ?
Regularly, particularly with new releases as indicated by the spotlight feature
Does it have graded cards in stock ?
Yes, they carry graded cards including those from PSA and BGS with a good selection of grades
Host break sessions ?
Not specified, but indicated interest in hosting events
Whats sports do they have ?
All major sports including baseball, basketball, football, and more
Trade in ?
Not specified
Community / Regular players ?
Yes, there appears to be an active collector community with general meetups and social interactions noted
Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?
Staff is described as passionate and knowledgeable about collectibles
Pro tips :
Check their weekly spotlight for new arrivals and sales
Engage with the staff for specific item inquiries, as they are knowledgeable and willing to help
Map
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.

