The Collector’s Cave Staten Island

The Collector’s Cave is positioned as a vibrant location for both sports and trading card enthusiasts, featuring a friendly and knowledgeable staff, as well as a good selection of cards and memorabilia. However, many reviews express concerns about their pricing being above market value and inconsistent customer service and reliability, especially regarding special orders and product availability. While some customers praise the fair buying policies and positive community events, others recommend seeking alternatives due to negative experiences. Overall, the store appears to have potential but suffers from trust issues with its clientele.

• Trading nights for community engagement
• Dungeons and Dragons gaming sessions
• Extensive selection of Funko Pops and action figures

Prices :

Booster boxes: typically overpriced (reports indicate double MSRP); Singles: approx. $1-100; TCG items: generally above market value

Speciality :

Trading card games and sports cards, particularly in modern releases

Event Schedule :

Best for :

Casual collectors, TCG players, and hobbyists looking for community engagement

FAQ :

Does it have vintage sports cards ?

No

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have graded cards in stock ?

Yes, offers graded cards, but selection details are not specified

Host break sessions ?

Yes, they host trading and gaming nights

Whats sports do they have ?

All major sports

Trade in ?

Offers cash or store credit at fair prices

Community / Regular players ?

Yes, has an active community with gaming events and trading nights

Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?

Staff appears knowledgeable but negative reviews suggest potential lapses in expertise or integrity

Pro tips :

Inquire about events and trading nights for a community experience

Check prices and availability before making special orders to avoid delays