Profile
Customers consistently praise Overtime Cards for its friendly and knowledgeable staff, excellent selection of sports and non-sports cards, and fair pricing. Many enjoy the welcoming atmosphere that encourages family visits, and there’s a strong sense of community among collectors. The store also offers a variety of products from different sports, including Pokémon and Magic cards. While parking may be limited, the overall shopping experience, including helpful service and frequent restocking, seems to outweigh any minor inconveniences.
- Community-focused environment with attentive staff
- Ripping counter for live breaks and card openings
- Customized experiences for collectors of all ages
Prices :
Singles: $0.50-100+, Sealed packs: $5-30, Hobby boxes: $100-300
Speciality :
A diverse selection of modern sports cards and collectibles, with a strong emphasis on customer relationships and community engagement.
Event Schedule :
Best for :
Casual fans and dedicated collectors looking for a friendly atmosphere and good deals.
FAQ :
Does it have vintage sports cards ?
Not specified
Does it restock frequently ?
Frequent restocking for new releases and popular items as per customer reviews
Does it have graded cards in stock ?
Yes, they have graded cards including PSA grades.
Host break sessions ?
Yes, they host box/case breaks with live experiences
Whats sports do they have ?
All major sports including baseball, basketball, soccer, football, hockey, as well as Pokémon and Magic cards.
Trade in ?
Not specified
Community / Regular players ?
Yes, has an active community with collector events and meetups mentioned.
Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?
Staff are described as very knowledgeable and helpful about sports cards and market values.
Pro tips :
Visit regularly for new drops and popular releases
Engage with staff for recommendations and card valuation assistance
Map
Sorry, no records were found. Please adjust your search criteria and try again.
Sorry, unable to load the Maps API.

