Indy Card Exchange Fishers

Indy Card Exchange is highly praised for its extensive selection of sports cards, friendly and knowledgeable staff, and a welcoming atmosphere that caters to collectors of all ages. Customers appreciate the store’s focus on community engagement through events and a Kids Club, but some have noted limitations on trade-ins and challenges in obtaining assistance with non-sport items or certain grading inquiries.

• Kids Club that provides discounts and rewards for young collectors
• Custom framing services for cards
• Expert grading service in collaboration with popular organizations (PSA, BGS, etc.)

Prices :

Singles: $0.50-1000+, Graded cards: Starting from $23/card depending on service level, Hobby boxes: $100-500, Lower budget cards available

Speciality :

Graded cards and a broad selection of both modern and vintage sports cards

Event Schedule :

Best for :

Casual collectors and families looking for an accessible starting point in card collecting

FAQ :

Does it have vintage sports cards ?

Yes, they carry vintage cards (pre-1980s) and have a good selection of them as mentioned in reviews.

Does it restock frequently ?

Not specified

Does it have graded cards in stock ?

Yes, they offer grading submission services with companies like PSA and SGC.

Host break sessions ?

Yes, they host live box breaks and have a presence on social media platforms for streaming these events

Whats sports do they have ?

All major sports including MLB, NBA, NFL, NHL, and some soccer

Trade in ?

Trade-ins are accepted but only for PSA graded cards, which may limit some customers

Community / Regular players ?

Yes, there is an active collector community with events and a Kids Club to encourage younger collectors

Is the staff knowledgeable in cards ?

Staff is described as very knowledgeable and helpful, skilled in assisting with various collecting needs and inquiries

Pro tips :

Take advantage of the Kids Club for discounts and promotions for young collectors

Follow their social media for announcements on live breaks and events